We continue with our in-depth research into the Hebrew Roots Movement (HRM). It is also known as Hebraic Roots and Jewish Roots. You can read the introduction to this series here.
Adherents of HRM believe that Christianity left its Hebrew Roots centuries ago and that what they are doing now is bringing Christianity back to its “roots.”
The research format for this series is in two sections:
- Section One — what adherents and critics believe about the doctrine and practice of the Hebrew Roots Movement
- Section Two — what I believe about the doctrine and practice of the Hebrew Roots Movement
We are still in Section One of this series.
[*We do not necessarily endorse the critics listed below or their ministries or websites. Our purpose is to share some of the oppositional viewpoints to beliefs in the Hebrew Roots Movement. I will share my observations in the second section of this series.]
One Law and Two House Theology
One of the beliefs of the Hebrew Roots Movement (HRM) is that Gentiles keep the Law through the One Law and Two House theology. What is that? Let’s see how HRM teachers explain it. We’ll look at critiques of the beliefs in the next part of our series.
One Law theology involves the claim that Gentiles are commanded by God to observe the Torah in the same way as the Jewish people. A key verse used by proponents of One Law theology is Numbers 15:16, “There will be one law for you and for the foreigner who resides with you.” One Law Theology
As a strong proponent of the One Law position, I have consistently taught that Gentiles who come to faith in Yeshua do not “become Jews,” but remain redeemed Gentiles who join the remnant of Israel and therefore demonstrate the faithfulness of God to the Abrahamic promise.
But this whole matter of maintaining a distinction between Jews and Gentiles needs to be considered more thoroughly. Much depends upon the vantage point of the one making the assessment. What I mean by this is simply that for “outsiders,” that is, for those outside of a Torah community who are assessing what they see of the community, it may well appear that Gentile members of the community are Jewish. This is because the Gentile members of the community participate in activities that have traditionally been labeled as “Jewish.” But for those within the Torah community itself, things might be seen quite differently. I know this is the case in our own community. It is not uncommon for a non-Jewish member of our community to relate his or her experience, in which someone in their neighborhood, or in a public place, asks them if they are Jewish. The question is reasonable because they’re wearing tzitzit, or buying kosher foods, or picking up challah for their Shabbat meal. The answer the inquirer receives, however, is something like this: “No, I’m not Jewish, but my Messiah is, and I’m seeking to walk in His footsteps.”
It seems that this same kind of scenario obtained even in the 1st Century. The idea that Jews were easily recognized as distinct from their Gentile friends is not well supported by the historical data. We do know that many Gentiles regularly visited synagogues in the early centuries, and even though many did not undergo rabbinic conversion, they adhered to a great deal of traditional Jewish halachah and lifestyle. Significantly, the fiscus judaicus, the so-called “Jewish tax,” was assessed upon all who ad-hered to “Jewish practice,” that is, who had a lifestyle characterized by Torah observance. Even before the second revolt, according to Suetonius, during the reign of Domitian (81–96 CE) his agents assessed the fiscus judaicus upon those they presumed to be “Jewish” on the basis of their lifestyle. Torah Resource
Two-House centers on two main theses: First, that the tribes of the Northern Kingdom, usually referred to as the Ten Lost Tribes, did not disappear into history, and second, that many if not most Christians today are descended from them. We actually agree on the first point, as we will show; it is the second point that is a matter of contention.
It should be noted that the degree to which the second thesis is taken differs from group to group. Some, taking very seriously Yeshua’s statement, “I wasn’t sent to anyone but the lost sheep of the house of Israel” (Mat. 15:24), believe that all Christians are actually descendants of the Northern Kingdom. It was in response to these individuals that the MJAA wrote its white paper: The Ephraimite Error: A Short Summary.
However, in the interest of fairness, we must note that not all take this extreme stance. For example, TNN Online outlines their beliefs as follows:
Based on these three paragraphs, there are indeed some truthful statements concerning what TNN Online believes and advocates concerning the reunion of all Israel:
1. We do believe that many non-Jewish Believers (“Christians”) may be flesh-and-blood descendants of the Northern Kingdom Israelites captured and dispersed by Assyria in 722-721 B.C.E.
2. We do believe that non-Jewish Believers in Yeshua are coming to a knowledge of their Hebraic heritage and should obey God’s Torah.
3. We do believe that one day people of the scattered House of Israel/Ephraim will return to the Land of Israel, just as the House of Judah has, in fulfillment of critical end-time prophecies such as: Isaiah 11:14; Jeremiah 3:18, 30:3; and Zechariah 10:7, 10.
However, there are some mistruths in these statements as well, with which TNN Online as an advocate of the Two-House teaching does not agree:
1. We do not believe that every non-Jew or “Christian” is a physical Israelite.
2. We do not believe that the scattered descendants of the Northern Kingdom of Israel/Ephraim are exclusively contained in areas populated by the British, i.e., Anglo-Saxons and Celts, or for that same matter, Northern Europeans. Hebrew Root
Along the journey of discovering the Hebrew Roots of my faith, I’ve picked up on a few interesting theologies, one of which is the Two House Theory. Essentially, this school of thought teaches that Christians are one of the lost Tribes of Israel and that God is uniting them with the house of Judah (i.e. the Jews) into one House under the New Covenant.
Historically, we know that after King Solomon died, all of Israel was divided into two regions: The Northern Kingdom of Israel & the Southern Kingdom of Judah. The division was caused by North’s lack of allegiance to Solomon’s successor. In 722 BC, the Assyrians conquered the Northern Kingdom, forcing the 10 tribes that inhabited the land to scatter and eventually become “lost”.
Those who follow the Two House theory suggest that the Assyrian conquering is a direct fulfillment of this blessing forcing Ephraim to scatter and become several nations. And to further support their position they refer to a passage in Romans 11, wherein the Apostle Paul describes Gentiles as being grafted into the root of Jesse in order to receive the blessings of God.
I think Christians feel slighted if they are not Messianic Jews because of the promises made to Israel in the Old Testament, because we have come to associate them with the covenant of Salvation. When in reality, some of God’s promises were to a physical Israel and to a land that he promised them. Has nothing to do with salvation or Christ’s sacrifice. In fact, Yeshua flat out states that His kingdom (not the Kingdom of Ancient Israel) is a spiritual one:
“My kingdom is not of this world. If my kingdom were of this world, my servants would have been fighting, that I might not be delivered over to the Jews. But my kingdom is not from the world. John 18:36
I don’t think we need to concern ourselves with trying to be Jewish as Christians. If you are a Jew coming from Judaism as Paul did (see Galatians 1:13) or you are Gentile, the promises made about the Ephraim and the division of the land has no bearing on your Salvation. Don’t worry about it. You are not less in the eyes of the Father because you don’t live in Israel or have Jewish blood. Two House Theory – Are Gentiles Being Grafted Into Israel
Furthermore, an important aspect of the gospel message would also include a belief in the restoration of the two houses of Israel (a regathering of the lost sheep of the house of Israel, see Matt 10:6; 15:24), or the restoration tabernacle of David (Acts 15:16), and that when believers are “born again” they become the one new man, become redeemed Israelites and are part of the covenants and commonwealth of Israel (Eph 2:11–19), and are the offspring of Abraham (Gal 3:39; Rom 4:16; 9:8–11). These saints comprised of Jews and non-Jews that have been gathered in from the nation are “the Israel of Elohim,” as Paul terms it (Gal 6:16). What Are the Fundamentals of the Hebraic Christian Faith?
eBook
You can download free eBooks of Chapters One – Five of this study here and Chapters Six – Thirteen here. Please share with family and friends as God leads.
Next Time
In the next part of our special series, The ‘Hebrew Roots’ Movement, we’ll look at some of the ‘critiques’ of the HRM belief in the “One Law” and “Two House” theology.
Faith & Self Defense © 2027

